The Opening of Chinese Credit Markets_thumbnail.jpg
Research & Insights

The Opening of Chinese Credit Markets Means That Foreign Investors Can Build a Balanced Portfolio in China; This Will Be a Big Deal

As you are likely aware, we have been deeply engaged in China for over 30 years. Throughout this time, we have built a rich understanding of the Chinese economy and markets and we have developed meaningful relationships with Chinese clients and policy makers. China is in the process of opening up and restructuring its capital markets, and its markets are on pace to become some of the most important liquid, publicly traded markets in the world. As most global investors are underweight Chinese assets relative to the size of the economy and markets, the opening up will likely lead to significant restructuring of global portfolios.

Chinese assets work fundamentally the same way as assets in other countries do, but China’s economic conditions are often different. As a result, Chinese assets are a valuable source of diversification. As the credit markets open up alongside the equity markets, there is a greater ability for investors to create balanced portfolios of Chinese assets as well. By balancing Chinese assets that have offsetting sensitivities to shifts in the Chinese economic environment, investors can expect to produce more consistent returns than an investment in just equities. The following highlights our thoughts on the opening up of the markets, which we expect will lead to a wave of inflows.

Chinese Asset Markets Are Large and Liquid

It is unprecedented that such large markets become available to investors so quickly. For perspective, the recent opening of Chinese markets is roughly equivalent to the German, French, and Italian asset markets all becoming available to investors in the space of less than two years. China now has the world’s second-largest equity market and the third-largest sovereign bond market, as shown in the table below.

The Opening of Chinese Credit Markets_table01_fo.svg

Over the past several years, these markets have gone from being essentially closed to foreign investors to almost completely open to foreign investors. While in 2015 only about 10% of Chinese capital markets were accessible to foreigners, today that figure is close to 80%, or about $13 trillion.

The Opening of Chinese Credit Markets_chart01_fo.svg

From the standpoint of Chinese policy makers, this evolution makes sense and is consistent with the gradual moves underway since 1978. Opening capital markets will attract stable pools of global institutional investment, deepen capital markets, and create two-way flows in the currency.

For global investors, this now means their portfolios are inadvertently significantly underweight Chinese markets relative to China’s size and accessibility. With Chinese assets increasingly being incorporated into the larger benchmark indices, foreign holdings of Chinese assets could rise by nearly two trillion dollars over time, as shown in the charts below.

The Opening of Chinese Credit Markets_chart02_fo.svg

Chinese Assets Work the Same Way as Global Assets

In the most important ways, assets behave similarly across countries. In general, assets that have higher risks than cash have risk premiums relative to cash. And the relationship between economic environments and assets is universal because it is based on the fundamental nature of the assets’ cash flows (i.e., bonds are fixed cash flows, equity cash flows move with earnings, and so on).

Assets generally have a risk premium relative to cash. Below, we illustrate this relationship since 1970 in the US and the corresponding picture in Chinese asset markets since 2005. As you can see, assets have similar Sharpe ratios (the ratio of return above cash relative to volatility) over the long term. However, as the bottom chart shows, individual asset class performance can vary significantly over shorter periods. The history of Chinese assets is relatively short, but the average Sharpe ratio across assets is positive, like that of US assets over a much longer time frame.

The Opening of Chinese Credit Markets_table02_fo.svg
The Opening of Chinese Credit Markets_chart03_fo.svg
1 Data for US assets from January 1970 through August 2017 in USD. Data for Chinese assets from August 2002 through August 2017 in CNY.

Changes in asset prices are primarily caused by economic surprises, specifically growth and inflation surprises. This is because asset returns are logically linked to the volume of economic activity (growth) and the pricing of that activity (inflation). These sensitivities are logical consequences of the assets' cash flows, and independent of the country of issuance. For example, you would logically expect stocks and bonds to have opposite biases to growth surprises. Stocks give you a claim on future earnings, so they are worth more when earnings and the economy are stronger than expected. Bonds give you a fixed stream of payments and discount a forward path of interest rates for valuing those payments, so they do better when interest rates fall due to unforeseen economic weakness.

Note that nothing in the above logic is dependent on geography—it is universally true based on the very nature of the asset classes themselves. This allows one to construct a portfolio that is balanced to economic surprises with global assets or with the assets of a single country. As shown below, both global and Chinese assets have historically performed consistently with these logical expectations.

The Opening of Chinese Credit Markets_chart04_fo.svg

The differences in how assets perform in different environments allow one to put together a balanced portfolio of assets that diversifies away the environmental bias of any one asset and achieves a more consistent return stream.

Chinese Conditions Are Different, Meaning Chinese Assets Are Diversifying to Global Assets

While China has a large influence on other major economies and vice versa, growth is primarily driven by the domestic economy, not exports, and China is at a different point in the long-term debt cycle than the developed world. Japan, Europe, and the US all have debt levels over 300% of GDP, interest rates close to zero, large central bank balance sheets, and growth well below 5%—none of which is true in China. All of these factors mean that conditions in China look different than in the countries that dominate institutional portfolios, as shown in the charts below.

The Opening of Chinese Credit Markets_chart05_fo.svg

Since changes in conditions are the primary driver of changes in asset prices, the differences between Chinese conditions and global conditions imply that you would expect Chinese assets to be lowly correlated to the assets that make up most institutional portfolios. Historically, this has been true, as seen in the charts below. As China’s markets continue to open up and global capital flows more freely, correlations will likely rise somewhat as ebbs and flows in global liquidity begin to have more impact, but we expect the fundamentally diversifying effects of Chinese assets will persist.

The Opening of Chinese Credit Markets_chart06_fo.svg

Another big difference between Chinese conditions and global conditions is the monetary “fuel in the tank”—the capacity for the central bank to ease should conditions require it. This is a consequence of China and the developed world being at different points in the long-term debt cycle. In developed economies, the lack of fuel in the tank is probably the single biggest risk to all beta portfolios. In the event of a downturn in which central banks need to ease and lack the “fuel” to do so, risky assets could perform extremely poorly. In China, this risk is minimal, as there is room for rates to fall both at the short end and the long end of the curve.

The Opening of Chinese Credit Markets_chart07_fo.svg

While Chinese labor and goods have reshaped the world in the past few decades, we expect Chinese capital markets to reshape the global financial landscape in the next decade. Given the opening of Chinese asset markets and the ability to invest in a responsible, balanced way, we expect that a wave of investment into Chinese financial assets is inevitable and imminent.

This research paper is prepared by and is the property of Bridgewater Associates, LP and is circulated for informational and educational purposes only. There is no consideration given to the specific investment needs, objectives or tolerances of any of the recipients. Additionally, Bridgewater’s actual investment positions may, and often will, vary from its conclusions discussed herein based on any number of factors, such as client investment restrictions, portfolio rebalancing and transactions costs, among others. Recipients should consult their own advisors, including tax advisors, before making any investment decision. This report is not an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to buy the securities or other instruments mentioned.

Bridgewater research utilizes data and information from public, private and internal sources, including data from actual Bridgewater trades. Sources include, 4Cast Inc., the Australian Bureau of Statistics, Asset International, Inc., Barclays Capital Inc., Bloomberg Finance L.P., CBRE, Inc., CEIC Data Company Ltd., Consensus Economics Inc., Credit Market Analysis Ltd., CreditSights, Inc., Corelogic, Inc., Costar Portfolio Strategy, Inc., Dealogic LLC, Ecoanalitica, Emerging Portfolio Fund Research, Inc., Empirical Research Partners, LLC, Eurasia Group Ltd., European Money Markets Institute – EMMI, Factset Research Systems, Inc., The Financial Times Limited, GaveKal Research Ltd., Global Financial Data, Inc., Harvard Business Review, Haver Analytics, Inc., The Investment Funds Institute of Canada, Intercontinental Exchange (ICE), Investment Company Institute, International Energy Agency, Investment Management Association, Markit Economics Limited, Mergent, Inc., Metals Focus Ltd, Moody’s Analytics, Inc., MSCI, Inc., National Bureau of Economic Research, North Square Blue Oak, Ltd , Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development, Pensions & Investments Research Center, RealtyTrac, Inc., RP Data Ltd, Roubini Global Economics, LLC, Rystad Energy, Inc., S&P Global Market Intelligence Inc., Sentix Gmbh, Shanghai Wind Information Co., Ltd., Spears & Associates, Inc., State Street Bank and Trust Company, Thomson Reuters, Tokyo Stock Exchange, TrimTabs Investment Research, Inc., United Nations, US Department of Commerce, World Bureau of Metal Statistics, World Economic Forum, and Wood Mackenzie Limited. While we consider information from external sources to be reliable, we do not assume responsibility for its accuracy.

The views expressed herein are solely those of Bridgewater as of the date of this report and are subject to change without notice. Bridgewater may have a significant financial interest in one or more of the positions and/or securities or derivatives discussed. Those responsible for preparing this report receive compensation based upon various factors, including, among other things, the quality of their work and firm revenues

Stay Informed
Sign up to receive our latest research on the forces shaping global economies and markets.
You're almost finished.
You will receive an email confirmation shortly.
There's been an error. Please start over and try again.
Stay Informed
Sign up to receive our latest research on the forces shaping global economies and markets.

Disclaimer & Agreement

Bridgewater Associates, LP is a global investment management firm. Bridgewater Associates, LP advises certain private investment funds and institutional clients, and is not available to provide investment advisory or similar services to most other investors. This website is a resource for audiences other than investors such as potential employees, researchers, students, counterparties and industry participants. Bridgewater Associates, LP believes it is useful for such persons to have an accurate source of relevant information. Under no circumstances should any information presented on this website be construed as an offer to sell, or solicitation of any offer to purchase, any securities or other investments. This website does not contain the information that an investor should consider or evaluate to make a potential investment. Offering materials relating to investments in entities managed by Bridgewater Associates, LP are not available to the general public.

To view this content, you must agree to the following terms, in addition to and supplementing the Bridgewater Terms of Use and Privacy Policy:

I confirm to Bridgewater Associates, LP and agree that:
  • I am entering this website only to obtain general information regarding Bridgewater Associates, LP and not for any other purpose.
  • I understand that investments managed by Bridgewater Associates, LP are not available to the general public.
  • I understand that this website does not contain the information I would need to consider for an investment, and that such information is only available to a limited group of persons and institutions meeting specified criteria.
  • I understand that this website has not been reviewed or approved by, filed with, or otherwise furnished to any governmental or similar authority, and is intended only to provide limited information to members of the public who have a legitimate interest in that information for reasons unrelated to making investments.
  • I understand that when Bridgewater Associates, LP makes third party information available, Bridgewater generally will not have verified statements made by the third party, and the presentation of information may omit important information.
  • I understand that third party materials such as live interviews made available by Bridgewater Associates, LP generally will not have been edited by Bridgewater and statements in those materials by individuals associated with Bridgewater should be understood in the conversational context in which they were made, which may include providing historical background.
  • The content constitutes the proprietary intellectual property of Bridgewater or its licensors and that I will not directly or indirectly copy, modify, recast, create derivative works, post, publish, display, redistribute, disclose, or make available the content, in whole or in part, to any third parties, or assist others to do the same, or otherwise make any commercial use of the content without the prior written consent of Bridgewater.

By registering my information below and clicking "Agree," I certify that I have read, understand and agree to the foregoing Disclaimer, Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
This website uses cookies. Click here for additional details. By continuing to use this website, you consent to the use of cookies.

Internet Explorer is not supported by this website.

For optimal browsing we recommend using Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.