Research & Insights

ESG stocks are not in a bubble

Despite rush by investors, valuations are not overextended

Re-published with permission from the Financial Times, the original article can be found here. The writer is co-chief investment officer for sustainability at Bridgewater Associates.

The rush by investors of all stripes to prioritise environmental, social and governance goals has raised speculation of an emerging bubble in favoured stocks.

But the shift to ESG appears to be still in its early innings. Investor positioning in sustainable equities is not yet overextended.

Most common ESG indices have very similar valuation characteristics to the broad market. The valuation of ESG stocks is roughly the same as a global equity portfolio. The ratio of price to average earnings over the past three years is moderate at about 14 for both.

And when we assess the most popular US ESG stocks using our “bubble gauge”— a measure that combines traditional valuation metrics with factors such as the pace of new buyers, the amount of purchases funded with borrowings and whether priced-in conditions seem sustainable — only a handful of popular ESG stocks appear especially frothy.

The US ESG index looks very similar to the aggregate market, and much less frothy than stocks that have been most popular with retail investors where we think valuations are most stretched.

A few sectors that seem significantly overweight in ESG indices compared with the broader market, such as renewable electricity, have moderately higher valuations. However, these constitute only a small weighting in market benchmarks.

Why is the valuation of ESG stocks so similar to that of the overall market? One reason is that common ESG indices track the market relatively closely and intentionally avoid making large deviations.

In other words, they effectively cut out “the worst” companies rather than choosing to hold only “the very best”. As a result, these indices end up looking a lot like a typical equity allocation. They avoid directing a large portion of their capital towards a limited number of sustainability-focused stocks.

ESG 1.png

Another reason for the valuation of ESG stocks remaining in line with the market is that the shift to sustainability has been gradual — at least until recently.

We analysed the disclosed equity holdings of a group of institutional investors that have publicly expressed significant interest in ESG, accounting for about $1.5tn in public equity assets. The moves they have made so far have been gradual and are not nearly as big as it would take to fully align with ESG indices. But a greater shift is expected.

Tobacco offers a case study. The withdrawal from the sector was long-running, but by the 2000s ESG-conscious institutions had almost no investments there. These investors have also been shifting out of the oil and defence sectors for 10 years and 20 years respectively. The shift towards “good” ESG companies such as renewable energy producers has been similarly gradual, but it now appears to be accelerating.

We suspect that large ESG flows are still ahead of us. Currently, only 4 per cent to 5 per cent of the mutual fund and ETF universe is in ESG-labelled funds, according to a Bank of America analysis of Morningstar data.

ESG 2.png

It is easy to imagine flows accelerating at an even faster pace. European investors, the vanguard of the sustainability shift, are moving their assets to ESG funds at a rate of 6 per cent to 8 per cent a year — more than twice the global average.

As allocations rise, there is likely to be big inflows and outflows out of most stocks, leading to notable price moves, particularly in sectors such as water utilities and renewable electricity.

And while today’s most common ESG indices are only modestly different from the market portfolio, investors may begin to make more ambitious changes as the sustainable investing universe continues to evolve.

Investors may choose to focus their portfolios rather than hold a large array of stocks. As there are so many stocks to choose from in the world with similar fundamental exposures to macroeconomic conditions, there is little to gain in diversification by expanding the universe of stocks beyond a modest spread of holdings. Simple portfolio maths illustrate that the initial gains from diversification — moving from one to 50 stocks — are substantial, while the later gains — moving from 50 to 500 holdings — are very small.

Investors shifting to more focused portfolios of sustainable companies would have much larger implications on relative stock prices.

With a growing share of investors prioritizing impact and sustainability, we believe there is significant room for ESG flows to run — and that sustainable investing’s largest impacts on relative stock valuations as well as the incentives facing public corporations are still ahead of us.

Stay Informed
Sign up to receive our latest research on the forces shaping global economies and markets.
You're almost finished.
You will receive an email confirmation shortly.
There's been an error. Please start over and try again.
Stay Informed
Sign up to receive our latest research on the forces shaping global economies and markets.

Disclaimer & Agreement


Bridgewater Associates, LP is a global investment management firm. Bridgewater Associates, LP advises certain private investment funds and institutional clients, and is not available to provide investment advisory or similar services to most other investors. This website is a resource for audiences other than investors such as potential employees, researchers, students, counterparties and industry participants. Bridgewater Associates, LP believes it is useful for such persons to have an accurate source of relevant information. Under no circumstances should any information presented on this website be construed as an offer to sell, or solicitation of any offer to purchase, any securities or other investments. This website does not contain the information that an investor should consider or evaluate to make a potential investment. Offering materials relating to investments in entities managed by Bridgewater Associates, LP are not available to the general public.

To view this content, you must agree to the following terms, in addition to and supplementing the Bridgewater Terms of Use and Privacy Policy:

I confirm to Bridgewater Associates, LP and agree that:
  • I am entering this website only to obtain general information regarding Bridgewater Associates, LP and not for any other purpose.
  • I understand that investments managed by Bridgewater Associates, LP are not available to the general public.
  • I understand that this website does not contain the information I would need to consider for an investment, and that such information is only available to a limited group of persons and institutions meeting specified criteria.
  • I understand that this website has not been reviewed or approved by, filed with, or otherwise furnished to any governmental or similar authority, and is intended only to provide limited information to members of the public who have a legitimate interest in that information for reasons unrelated to making investments.
  • I understand that when Bridgewater Associates, LP makes third party information available, Bridgewater generally will not have verified statements made by the third party, and the presentation of information may omit important information.
  • I understand that third party materials such as live interviews made available by Bridgewater Associates, LP generally will not have been edited by Bridgewater and statements in those materials by individuals associated with Bridgewater should be understood in the conversational context in which they were made, which may include providing historical background.
  • The content constitutes the proprietary intellectual property of Bridgewater or its licensors and that I will not directly or indirectly copy, modify, recast, create derivative works, post, publish, display, redistribute, disclose, or make available the content, in whole or in part, to any third parties, or assist others to do the same, or otherwise make any commercial use of the content without the prior written consent of Bridgewater.

By registering my information below and clicking "Agree," I certify that I have read, understand and agree to the foregoing Disclaimer, Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
This website uses cookies. Click here for additional details. By continuing to use this website, you consent to the use of cookies.

Internet Explorer is not supported by this website.

For optimal browsing we recommend using Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.